EnjoyerMichigan Enjoyer
Photo of dilapidated classroom in old schoolhouse in northern Michigan, scribbled illegible text on chalkboard, american flag and bookshelf.
Politics

Teaching Confusion

How public schools kill curiosity

By James Dickson · July 11, 2024

A book I’ve been reading has helped me understand the threat that homeschools pose. “Dumbing Us Down: The Hidden Curriculum of Compulsory Schooling” by John Taylor Gatto, a best-seller for 30 years.

Gatto was a top educator in New York City. The chapters of the book are the speeches he gave while accepting teaching awards. Even while accepting the highest honors of his profession, Gatto saw there were problems with the education system in the very design of the thing. His contrarian takes are as fascinating as they are disturbing.

Gatto identifies the seven real lessons taught at school:

Graphic reads: Teaching Confusion How Public Schools Kill Curiosity Confusion Confusion is a fact of life, but bad schools actively groom students into a perpetual state of confusion. In bad schools, the schools you see on @LibsofTikTok, kids aren't just taught to accept confusion. Does your kid's public school classroom have an LGTBQ flag? You can bet they're learning confusion. Class Position Kids come to "know their place," not question it. Indifference If your insights stop being relevant after the dismissal bell, why bother learning? Emotional Dependency Grades, awards, and disciplinary actions condition students to outsource their will to the classroom's "chain of command." Intellectual Dependency Deference to experts becomes a precondition of thought. Provisional Self-esteem Students feel they're worth as much as they're told they are. Students Can't Hide In school, there are no private spaces for children, and no private time. Source: Dumbing Us Down: The Hidden Curriculum of Compulsory Schooling John Taylor Gatto

Every minute of the day is accounted for by the warden. Students are encouraged to tell on each other—and on their parents.

Just like that, context is built where teachers actually feel students are safer at school than they are at home. At school they “affirm” a kid in the sex dysphoria that they helped create. Parents can’t be trusted with that privileged information—it’s our little secret, between student and teacher.

It’s not hard to imagine a world where parents are removed entirely. The state is fully in charge of raising the children of humanity. They’re “our kids,” after all.

James David Dickson is host of the James Dickson Podcast.

Related Articles