
Harbor Springs Doesn’t Need Another Three-Story Box
A gravel lot off Main Street has the potential to become a nice little park or rental units, but which would be more human?
Harbor Springs — There’s this incredible book called “A Pattern Language: Towns, Buildings, Construction.” Though its name sounds very dry, stoically academic, and out of reach for the average person, it’s not any of those. Quite the opposite, in fact.
“A Pattern Language” was written in 1977 by a group arguing that ordinary people should design their homes, spaces, and towns rather than “professional” architects and planners. The most enduring and treasured places on earth were designed and kept this way, after all.
Over the past 50 years, the book has developed almost a cult following and a deep appreciation among just about anyone interested in cultivating a more human world. If you find yourself in conversation with others about topics like families, homes, warm life, beautiful places, traditions, and the human experience in built environments, there’s a general assumption that you are familiar with “A Pattern Language.”

The book was very relevant in 1977, a time when older buildings were being bulldozed, with new, often inhuman buildings rising up in their places. And it’s just as relevant nearly half a century later as we see the cultural steamroller of new builds erected for short-term rentals, the erosion of human-scaled spaces, and the collapse of the quaint for the sake of the efficient and the profitable.
“A Pattern Language” is also quite relevant on the corner of Main and Gardner Street up north in little Harbor Springs.
If you’ve never been to Harbor Springs, it’s basically like the world before. It’s a Norman Rockwell painting, an old photograph; the quintessential American village. There’s no stoplight, the whole downtown could fit inside the parking lot of the Traverse City Costco (no exaggeration, that’s a fact), and, like all towns used to be, every little building means something, because there just aren’t that many of them, and the newer one is the more it sticks out, and not in a good way.
So when some piece of land goes up for sale or is primed for development in Harbor, it’s of great interest to most who live there. Currently, the lot at the corner of Main and Gardner is on the table, and it presents a perfect fork in the road: One path leads toward human-centric public spaces and cultural preservation, and the other leads toward something unfortunate.

Currently, the lot is home to Running Water, a small fitness center with a name nodding to the historical spring waters that used to run down to the bay below. Behind the one-story building is a gravel parking lot bumping up against Third Street in the rear. Next door is one of the oldest buildings in Harbor Springs, currently home to an art studio with a bank of windows facing east, and across the street is the United Methodist Church, designed by Earl H. Mead and built in 1914.
It’s easy to imagine how in the right hands this back gravel lot might easily be converted into a small park with nice grass, shrubs, and perhaps a little gazebo or shelter in the middle. One characteristic of the most beautiful neighborhoods is the prevalence of grass, trees, and parks scattered about. They make a place feel less designed and more organic. The transformation of this gravel lot into a little park would have an outsize impact on the general feeling one gets walking down from the bluff, past the church and toward the water. A natural beautification of a place for the benefit of the community. It might be a wonderful transformation very in-line with the human-centric ideas of “A Pattern Language.”

What might be much worse would be a replica of what happened on the other side of Main.
There was once, until very recently, a green lot full of trees and a nice view over to the bay. Now, however, there is a huge three-story Lego-block building towering over Main blocking all views of the lake and any sunlight from the southwest. The building is out of character, hulking in size, and brings far more darkness than light. If the same thing were to be repeated across the street where Running Water and the gravel lot currently sit, the result would be dreadful and dark.
The Methodist church next door has incredibly beautiful stained glass windows facing west over Running Water. The sun in the evenings comes through the windows and casts colorful light on the old pews inside. The erection of a three-story building would mean the darkening of the stained glass. The light from the dipping sun that has brought the windows to life for over a century would be snuffed out for good. The houses on Third would lose any remaining views of Main or feeling of openness to the west and would face a towering structure more at home in Chicago than Harbor.

It’s very common to look back at photos of downtowns from the early 20th century and end up fairly sad afterward. People tore down a lot of old buildings that didn’t need to be torn down, and they built a lot of ugly stuff in the name of “progress” as they understood it. The result all these decades later is kind of mournful. Once something is gone, it’s not coming back, and once some massive new thing is built, it’s probably going to stay for a while. So all we are left with are these old photos of beautiful places that were disintegrated for no real good reason and the sad feeling that accompanies them.
None of the errors of those earlier decades had to happen. It wasn’t a law of nature that things were going to go the way they did. People could have made the choice to cultivate more human spaces, they could have fostered more beautiful little parks and fewer parking lots, and perhaps if “A Pattern Language” came out earlier they might have.

Thankfully, today we are able to see the mistakes of the past clearly and won’t make the same ones ourselves. We should know how clearly important green spaces, public parks, walkways, welcoming buildings, and stunning views are.
There’s an incredible opportunity at the corner of Main and Gardner. There’s a chance to make the right choice: to beautify and elevate a space, to open it to the people of the place, to make an already lovely place more so, to further enrich the human scale of a village, and let the light come through.


