Skip to main content
EnjoyerMichigan Enjoyer
Dark Michigan DNR pickup truck with a department logo on the door, parked beside a road at the edge of a leafy forest.
Accountability

The DNR Can Trespass On Your Land For Any Reason

Michigan conservation officers can still walk onto private land without a warrant

By Tom Zandstra · November 16, 2026

On opening day in 2025, a husband and wife were sitting in a deer tent on their own land in Newaygo County when a conservation officer walked up and asked for their licenses. A neighbor had complained that the couple was out there to spoil his hunt rather than hunt themselves, and on the video, the officer brings up an earlier run-in and says he will report the couple for harassment.

A federal judge in Grand Rapids threw out the couple's lawsuit in May, writing that the video "blatantly contradicted" parts of their account, and they have appealed. You don't have to take their side of a feud to see the bigger problem. Nobody asked a judge whether a neighbor's complaint was reason enough to send an armed officer onto that land, because in Michigan nobody has to.

That comes from the "open fields" doctrine, which the U.S. Supreme Court laid out in 1924 and reaffirmed in 1984. Land beyond a house and the yard around it gets no Fourth Amendment protection, the Court said, even behind a locked gate and a row of No Trespassing signs.

Every landowner in this state knows what those signs mean. They mean keep out, and that's supposed to mean everyone.

The people who wrote the Fourth Amendment had lived under the opposite idea. British customs officers carried general warrants called writs of assistance that let them search wherever they pleased, and when James Otis argued against them in a Boston courtroom in 1761, John Adams said later that the child Independence was born then and there.

Michigan DNR "Deer 2004 Successful Hunter" embroidered patches in a bag, priced at $10 in a red display box

A few years after that, an English judge wrote that every invasion of private property, however small, is a trespass. That is the tradition our founders were fighting for, and I doubt any of them would accept that a man's posted woods are open to any agent of the government who decides to walk in.

The DNR's argument deserves a fair hearing. The DNR told lawmakers that poachers can take wildlife while an officer waits on a warrant, and it says its officers already need a reason to go onto private land and must write it down. I want conservation officers catching people who shoot deer at night.

But a reason an officer writes down for himself is not a warrant, and Tennessee and Pennsylvania have both had courts rule that their wildlife officers need one, or the owner's permission, to search private land that owners use or have posted.

Michigan's House passed House Bill 4073 on Nov. 4, 2025, by a vote of 63 to 37, with four Democrats joining. It would require DNR officers to get a warrant or the landowner's consent before going onto private land. The Senate sent it to committee two days later, but it hasn't had a hearing since.

The session ends with the year, and every bill still sitting in committee dies with it. If the Senate lets this one die, the signs on every fence line in Michigan will keep meaning exactly what they say for everybody, except the state.

Tom Zandstra is a passionate outdoorsman and CEO of The Fair Chase.

Related Articles